While packing up our office, we stumbled across a gold mine of previously sold out boxes we think would be much happier on your bookshelves than moving with us! We're listing both Full Boxes (which include all the gifts but may be missing some or all of the original paperwork), and Partial Boxes (which may be missing up to 2 of the original gifts OR one of the gifts is unwrapped and will be shipped unwrapped within the box).

These boxes are from as far back as 2018 and have been sold out on our website for YEARS, so this is your only chance to grab them up! Box options include Adult, Young Adult, Tween, Middle Grade, and Limited Edition boxes including, but not limited to, Spooky, Sweet, Christmas, Advent, Bridgerton Volume 1, Middle Grade Summer Reading, Romantasy Volumes 1 and 2, and more! What you get is a total mystery, but it could be a box valued at up to $200!

These boxes are extremely limited in quantity and once they are gone, they are GONE! These are the very last of each of these past boxes and they will never be brought back!

Disclaimer: Mystery boxes may be from 2018 through 2024. Many boxes will be previously sold out but some boxes may still be available in our regular shop and were stored with the vault boxes. Partial boxes may include up to 50% of the original gifts including ratios of 2/3, 2/4, 3/5, 4/5, or 5/6. Partial boxes may also include all original gifts BUT a gift may be missing its original wrapping. Please note that with this gift unwrapped, we are now considering it as a bonus "item" and not a gift. Shopping the Mystery Box sale is a shop-at-your-own-risk sale, and may result in you receiving a box you have purchased before. Boxes cannot be requested or personalized to your order. Orders of multiple boxes may result in a duplicate box. Boxes ordered in the Mystery Box Sale are final sale and cannot be returned or exchanged. Shipping will be conducted quickly by our team, so please ensure your shipping information is correct prior to checking out.